join or sign in

Sign Up/ Login

Join or Sign-in using FaceBook account:

You can use your existing FaceBook account to join or sign-in to Discusscafe.com

If you do not have a Facebook account or if you do not want to use your faceBook account to join Discusscafe.com, click here.


North Versus South

i Trevor Cartwright
Category: Politics
Date: 20/02/2013
Tags:
?

Whose side would you have been on and why?

posted by Trevor Cartwright | suggest edit

Yes

I support the South

No

I support the North

DEBATE

add your argumensts in favor or against the issue

arguments supporting the issue
arguments against the issue

The South fought for their states' rights.

posted by Trevor Cartwright | suggest edit

0 likes 

lets do this!!! Well first and foremost the souths states rights were totally trampled. The north and all of its new rules and tarrifs (of abomination) was total discrimination against the south

posted by Nicholas Herrero | suggest edit

1 likes 

GOOOO NICK!

posted by Tyler Sorrels | suggest edit

3 likes 

ok, the slaves was a state right granted by congress earlier. There would have never been slaves without congress consent. 13th ammendment was for morale. That's all

posted by Nicholas Herrero | suggest edit

1 likes 

the north wanted free states

posted by Marc Garcia | suggest edit

0 likes 

;( the south's rights were being ignored like to two brothers the older one will pick on the littler one until he blows(civil war) IT WAS NOT PREATTY.

posted by Joey Giordano | suggest edit

0 likes 

okay, so first South was doing its own thing, and then all of a sudden, the North thinks their better than the South!! i mean who does that? South may have had slaves, but so did the North to! and all those rules, law, and taxes agaisn't the South, were really unfair for the South, i mean they didn't even do anything wrong, and the North doing the EXACT SAME THING were against them?

posted by Jessica Hines | suggest edit

2 likes 

Joey, that was worse argument I've ever seen

posted by Noah Tassi | suggest edit

1 likes 

The south were using their slaves for stuff they couldn't do alone. not all were abusing the slaves.

posted by Shelby Pristow | suggest edit

0 likes 

north had slaves too smart alecs (General Ulysses S. Grant thank you very much)

posted by Nicholas Herrero | suggest edit

1 likes 

BRENDEN AND NICK ARE BOTH WRONG

posted by Marc Garcia | suggest edit

3 likes 

NICK YOUR WRONG AND UN-SMART

posted by Brenden Foster | suggest edit

0 likes 

Some people needed slaves to run their plantations, and not all masters treated slaves bad. Some people treated slaves like family for example "Stonewall" Jackson

posted by Sean Fuller | suggest edit

1 likes 

the south should have the same rights

posted by luigi1 | suggest edit

0 likes 

U ARE ONE TO TALK BRENDEN

posted by Tyler Sorrels | suggest edit

1 likes 

go south!!!!!! we need states rights!!!

posted by Elias222 | suggest edit

0 likes 

YOUR MOM

posted by Brenden Foster | suggest edit

0 likes 

MR CARTWRIGHT

posted by Ron Peretz | suggest edit

0 likes 

Go marc, I agree with you

posted by Noah Tassi | suggest edit

0 likes 

those slaves were the south's way of life

posted by Nicholas Herrero | suggest edit

0 likes 

gooooo marrrc tell em!!!! woooo hooo

posted by Elias222 | suggest edit

0 likes 

Be quiet nick

posted by luigi1 | suggest edit

1 likes 

i know it was wrng fer the suth 2 have sleves but without the sleevs the suth's plantations wuld go out of business and the suth wuld loose luts uf money

posted by Joey Giordano | suggest edit

0 likes 

The south sometimes KILLED there slaves by over working them . You didnt see that in the north did you NICK

posted by Brenden Foster | suggest edit

0 likes 

People should have the same rights as everyone else. People could have maids or people working for them but they should get paid and be treated right ! :)

posted by Hailee Teer | suggest edit

1 likes 

The north was industrial and didn't need slaves. The south was agricultural and needed them to take care of and harvest the crops

posted by Andrew Buxmann | suggest edit

3 likes 

ANDREW IS THE BOMB!

posted by Noah Tassi | suggest edit

0 likes 

    .

posted by Noah Tassi | suggest edit

1 likes 

NO NOAH HE'S THE BOMB.COM

posted by Tyler Sorrels | suggest edit

1 likes 

:(

posted by Sean Fuller | suggest edit

0 likes 

the civil war, is just a lame excuse for the North to go to war against the south

posted by Jessica Hines | suggest edit

2 likes 

Nick, you have "amazing" arguments

posted by Noah Tassi | suggest edit

0 likes 

OK JESSICA KEEP TALKIN

posted by Joey Giordano | suggest edit

1 likes 

leedle leedle leedle!!!!!!!

posted by Shelby Pristow | suggest edit

2 likes 

why would the Union want alot of their citizens to die

posted by Nicholas Herrero | suggest edit

0 likes 

JESSICA IS ALWAYS WRONG

posted by Hailee Teer | suggest edit

1 likes 

Go black people and white people

posted by Noah Tassi | suggest edit

2 likes 

The south thought they were being overpowered because they had more population....So in turn they had more Representatives.

posted by Tyler Ames | suggest edit

3 likes 

thanks noah

posted by Nicholas Herrero | suggest edit

0 likes 

I LIKE CAKE

posted by Joey Giordano | suggest edit

1 likes 

I didn't mean it Nick, well maybe, I don't know

posted by Noah Tassi | suggest edit

2 likes 

HIIIII MARC!!!! :D

posted by Tyler Ames | suggest edit

0 likes 

LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE LEEDLE !!!!!!!

posted by Shelby Pristow | suggest edit

2 likes 

Hitler and the Civil War is totally different. First of all Hitler wanted to RULE the entire world, and thought Jews were horrible, but the Civil war is an EXCUSE

posted by Jessica Hines | suggest edit

0 likes 

Asians are amazingly amazing (that's for you Andrew), so are black people (that's for you Marc)

posted by Noah Tassi | suggest edit

1 likes 

BE QUIET AMES

posted by Tyler Sorrels | suggest edit

0 likes 

I AM WITH THE SOUTH BECAUSE I THINK THE NORTH IS WRONG WITH PRESERVING ITS UNION. THE SOUTH IS RIGHT FOR WANTING FREE RIGHTS

posted by Ron Peretz | suggest edit

0 likes 

NOAH JUST WANTS TO BE AN INSIDE OUT OREO

posted by Hailee Teer | suggest edit

3 likes 

Jessica it was not an excuse the south thought the North was treading on the Souths rights!

posted by Tyler Ames | suggest edit

1 likes 

I LOVE SOUTHERN

PEOPLE

posted by Ron Peretz | suggest edit

2 likes 

THEIR REALLY NICE

posted by Ron Peretz | suggest edit

1 likes 

ANDREW DONT JUDGE ME NEXT TIME

posted by Ron Peretz | suggest edit

0 likes 

They're Ron, they're

posted by Noah Tassi | suggest edit

0 likes 

FUZY WUZY

posted by Ron Peretz | suggest edit

0 likes 

HELLO PEOPLE OF MOTHER EARTH.

posted by Elias222 | suggest edit

1 likes 

WAS A BEAR

posted by Ron Peretz | suggest edit

0 likes 

YO MOM!

posted by Tyler Ames | suggest edit

0 likes 

I don't stand for slavery, but I do stand for state rights. The Civil War war was the beginning of a gradual growth of federal power. This has followed us to today. State rights have been virtually forgotten. Abortion can not be banned according to federal law. Obama care is another example. Again, I don't stand for slavery. But I'd rather fight slavery than fight tyranny, which is where we are heading if the gun ban is passed.

posted by Preston McGath | suggest edit

0 likes 

IS NICE I KNOW

posted by Ron Peretz | suggest edit

0 likes 

FUZZY HAD CANCER

posted by Elias222 | suggest edit

0 likes 

HE HAD NOOO HAIR

posted by Ron Peretz | suggest edit

0 likes 

THE NORTH WERE THE ONLY REASON WHY WE HAVE BASKETBALL AND STUFF

posted by Marc Garcia | suggest edit

1 likes 

the reason why the Civil War is just a lame excuse(NICK) to go to War is manly because of their economics, and law, and their tariffs. the North didn't like the way that South was handling them self how they just lived, i guess you could say, but the North and the South are exactly the SAME, same slaves, same living quarters, and same rules, well until the Civil War.the North just wanted power or so to say......... etc

posted by Jessica Hines | suggest edit

0 likes 

KJFESKJFKSJFKJEFKJAWKNDJSDBFN V I MADE MY POINT

posted by Elias222 | suggest edit

1 likes 

I HHHAVVVVEEE ARTHRITUS . AND IITSS KILLING MEEE!!

posted by Ron Peretz | suggest edit

0 likes 

Amesy poo bear!!!

posted by Trevor Cartwright | suggest edit

3 likes 

FUZY WUZY WAS A BEAR. FUZY WUZY HAD NO HAIR!

posted by Tyler Ames | suggest edit

0 likes 

boo bear.

posted by Kayla Cawthorn | suggest edit

0 likes 

ames is trying to hold my hand!!!!!!!!!! RAPE

posted by Shelby Pristow | suggest edit

0 likes 

AWTHRITUS IS SPREADING FFASST

posted by Ron Peretz | suggest edit

0 likes 

lol wow ames !!!!!

posted by Kayla Cawthorn | suggest edit

0 likes 

JUST NO KAYLA

posted by Tyler Ames | suggest edit

0 likes 

1

posted by Ron Peretz | suggest edit

0 likes 

Someone from the south killed Lincoln

posted by Tony Marquez | suggest edit

0 likes 

you got a problem with that. he is my relative.

posted by Kayla Cawthorn | suggest edit

0 likes 

really

posted by Tony Marquez | suggest edit

0 likes 

The North wanted to preserve the Union.

posted by Trevor Cartwright | suggest edit

1 likes 

I think you should have a whole nation instead of a split

posted by Jacea Tillman | suggest edit

2 likes 

The North is the best period.

posted by Brenden Foster | suggest edit

2 likes 

Well nick, what if the laws were for the better, slaves for example, where against the constitution and against GOD!!!

posted by Jacea Tillman | suggest edit

2 likes 

There was no provision in the Constitution that permitted succession so when southern states declared themselves independent they were in violation of that document.

posted by Brenden Foster | suggest edit

1 likes 

way to copy paste brenden

posted by Nicholas Herrero | suggest edit

1 likes 

The North used slaves, but not as much as the South, the South used slaves way more than the North.

posted by Noah Tassi | suggest edit

2 likes 

Lose morals for a little bit and think about the logistics people. seriously

posted by Nicholas Herrero | suggest edit

0 likes 

;(

posted by Joey Giordano | suggest edit

0 likes 

the North was way out of its league!

posted by Jessica Hines | suggest edit

0 likes 

I DIDNT COPY AND PASTE NICK

posted by Brenden Foster | suggest edit

0 likes 

What do you mean by way out of its league

posted by Nicholas Herrero | suggest edit

0 likes 

No one should be treated badly! We should all have the same rights. Like , black people shouldnt be treated bad. The south had slaves and the north didnt. For real people .

posted by Hailee Teer | suggest edit

1 likes 

I said lose morals for a little bit hailee

posted by Nicholas Herrero | suggest edit

2 likes 

Sorry for party rocking!!!!

posted by Shelby Pristow | suggest edit

1 likes 

You spelled Nich wrong Brenden. It's Nich, not Nick

posted by Noah Tassi | suggest edit

2 likes 

NORTH IS BETTER

posted by Brenden Foster | suggest edit

1 likes 

Some people treated slaves like family ("Stonewall" Jackson)

posted by Sean Fuller | suggest edit

1 likes 

ok well all of you who think i am unintelligent, go ask my mom what my iq is, she is the only person who knows and she says its pretty high, also, unsmart is not a word

posted by Nicholas Herrero | suggest edit

1 likes 

Nick don't go AGAINST my arguement!!!

posted by Jessica Hines | suggest edit

2 likes 

no salves

posted by heavyn | suggest edit

2 likes 

north had slaves to smart

posted by camrynmartinez | suggest edit

3 likes 

No one should have slaves, especially if they are being treated wrong. Black people are just as equal as us. What if the black were like the white and the white were like the black, would you like it if you were treated like that? I DIDN'T THINK SO

posted by KaylaFreund | suggest edit

3 likes 

good one camryn

posted by Tyler Sorrels | suggest edit

3 likes 

what does your argument mean Jessica

posted by Nicholas Herrero | suggest edit

2 likes 

the north is the best period

posted by camrynmartinez | suggest edit

3 likes 

go kayla

posted by heavyn | suggest edit

2 likes 

Marc stop flirting with camryn

posted by Jacea Tillman | suggest edit

6 likes 

the north is the nicest

posted by heavyn | suggest edit

2 likes 

if that was sarcasm noah, ill kill you

posted by Nicholas Herrero | suggest edit

0 likes 

It is sarcasm Nick

posted by Noah Tassi | suggest edit

0 likes 

GO CAMCAM!!!!!

posted by KaylaFreund | suggest edit

2 likes 

NICK

posted by Brenden Foster | suggest edit

0 likes 

SLAVES ARE NICE UNLIKE SOME PEOPLE

posted by KaylaFreund | suggest edit

1 likes 

GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO CCCCAAAAMMMM CCCCAAAAMMM

posted by heavyn | suggest edit

2 likes 

BOTH TYLERS HAVE BETTER IQ'S THAN NICK

posted by Joey Giordano | suggest edit

1 likes 

Ok so here is a real question if the south was in control how would orour society be today? @Nicholas Herrero

posted by Brenden Foster | suggest edit

0 likes 

Embarassed

it would rock@nicholasLaughing

posted by heavyn | suggest edit

1 likes 

sssssssssssshhhhhhhhhhhh I'M TRYING TO READ!!!!!!1

posted by Joey Giordano | suggest edit

0 likes 

the north had a right to take the right.

posted by Kayla Cawthorn | suggest edit

0 likes 

:)

posted by KaylaFreund | suggest edit

0 likes 

The south wouldn't be in control. They would be a separate nation. @Brenden Foster

posted by Sean Fuller | suggest edit

0 likes 

jk it would stink

posted by heavyn | suggest edit

0 likes 

What do you mean Kayla

posted by KaylaFreund | suggest edit

0 likes 

The north had a right to take what right?

posted by KaylaFreund | suggest edit

0 likes 

CoolEmbarassedLaughinglook

posted by heavyn | suggest edit

2 likes 

I LOVE YOU HEAVYN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

posted by camrynmartinez | suggest edit

1 likes 

I LOVE YOU TOO

posted by heavyn | suggest edit

1 likes 

I LOVE YOU CAMMMMCAMMMMMMMM!!!!!!!!!

posted by KaylaFreund | suggest edit

1 likes 

north had to detian the south.

posted by Kayla Cawthorn | suggest edit

0 likes 

Discuss

got some issues? Discuss with the community members

I am

 

of the south, read my essay punks

Posted by Nicholas Herrero on 20/02/2013 at 03:58 PM

0 likes  Reply

 

JSFKZXJKJDDKFDSKJSKDCNKSNVJNKMDX;C XKJCDKMXC KZJLMC LSDFLKXC,M ZJDNXKÇ≥JSL; SDKJLFDL JDSV

Posted by Elias222 on 20/02/2013 at 03:56 PM

0 likes  Reply

 

LEAVE ME ALONE SORRELS

Posted by Tyler Ames on 20/02/2013 at 03:56 PM

0 likes  Reply

 

JSFKZXJKJDDKFDSKJSKDCNKSNVJNKMDX;C XKJCDKMXC KZJLMC LSDFLKXC,M ZJDNXKÇ≥JSL; SDKJLFDL JDSV

Posted by Elias222 on 20/02/2013 at 03:55 PM

0 likes  Reply

 

heyyyyy

Posted by Kayla Cawthorn on 20/02/2013 at 03:54 PM

0 likes  Reply

 

GO AWAY AMES

Posted by Tyler Sorrels on 20/02/2013 at 03:53 PM

0 likes  Reply

 

HIIIII

Posted by Tyler Ames on 20/02/2013 at 03:51 PM

0 likes  Reply

 

Who would be the smarter side to chose North or South in the civil war.

Posted by Brenden Foster on 20/02/2013 at 03:44 PM

0 likes  Reply

no

Posted by Hailee Teer on 20/02/2013 at 03:47 PM

1 likes  Reply

Action in process


Please wait........